Goochland Voted Republican—Then Voted Yes on the Amendments
Goochland County delivered clear Republican wins on November 3. Bert Mizusawa took the U.S. Senate race by roughly 6.5 points (53.15% to 46.63%). John McGuire carried the county for Congress by about 10.4 points (54.37% to 43.99%). Those are comfortable margins in a competitive midterm.
The same voters then passed two constitutional amendments that most Republican leadership and activists had opposed. Amendment 1 (reproductive freedom) won 52.55% to 47.45%. Amendment 2 (removing the same-sex marriage ban) passed more narrowly, 50.96% to 49.04%. Only Amendment 3 (automatic restoration of voting rights for released felons) lost, 56.02% No to 43.98% Yes.
The pattern is hard to ignore. Republican candidates won. The party’s preferred positions on the first two amendments did not. That is not a messaging failure confined to one race. It is a measurable gap between the candidates voters supported and the policy questions they answered the same day.
Exclude Precinct 403 (West Creek), the county’s clearest Democratic stronghold, and the picture changes only slightly. Amendment 1 still passes. Amendment 2 flips to No. The remaining county still does not produce a clean Republican alignment on the amendments.
Remove the three eastern precincts that most heavily favored the Yes side—403, 402 (Centerville), and 502 (Blair)—and the county votes No on all three. Those three precincts supplied the entire countywide Yes margin on Amendment 1 and the decisive margin on the narrow Yes for Amendment 2. The rest of Goochland was not with them.
The numbers do not prove that every Yes voter is a Democrat or that every Republican voter misunderstood the amendments. They do show that a significant share of people who voted for Mizusawa and McGuire also voted Yes on measures the party broadly opposed. Precinct 403 is a Democratic domain and can be set aside for the purpose of this discussion. The remaining data still reveal a gap between the Republican ticket and the amendment outcomes. Closing that gap will require clearer communication on the substance of the amendments, not simply stronger candidate performance.
Background: Before the Vote
Before the vote, this post asked whether the remaining horsemen of the Virginia Constitution Apocalypse could be stopped like redistricting was on April 21st. The note then was “Maybe. Just Maybe. Like, Comment, and Share.” It also included a music video, and it said a music video is one thing – turnout is quite another.
Be the first to comment